Desperate measures: Pakistani women seek abortions as birth control

PESHAWAR:Pregnant, desperate, and poor, Pakistani mother Zameena faced a stark choice: risk her life by having a secret abortion, or risk her life bearing her husband a sixth child.

In the end, she opted for the former, one of more than two million women a year to do so in a country where religious leaders are critical of family planning measures and there is a lack of sex education and access to contraception.

Almost half of all pregnancies in Pakistan — around 4.2 million each year — are unplanned and around 54 per cent of those end in termination, according to a report by US research firm Guttmacher Institute.

“Three years ago, when my daughter was born, the doctor told me that I should stop having babies because it would be bad for my health,” said Zameena, using an assumed name, from her home in the northwest city of Peshawar.

“But whenever I say that to my husband, he tells me to trust God,” the 35-year-old added. “My husband is a religious man… he wants to have a line of sons.”

Decades ago, a family planning campaign with the slogan “do bache hi ache” or “two children is good” was rejected by religious leaders as well as nationalists who wanted a bigger population to rival the 1.2 billion people in neighbouring India.

Today with a population of around 207 million, Pakistan’s baby boom is stretching resources beyond capacity and experts warn of trouble ahead.

Zameena said she frequently suggested to her husband that they practice family planning, but he refused.

“My mother-in-law had nine kids,” said Zameena. “When I complain to my husband that I can’t have more babies, he answers: ‘If my mother didn’t die, you should also stay alive’.”

Abortion is allowed in Pakistan if the health of the mother is in danger. But many doctors invoke their Muslim faith and refuse to carry them out.

As a result, some women abort illegally and authorities largely turn a blind eye to the situation.

The preferred method is by ingesting Misoprostol, an over-the-counter drug used to treat ulcers, which causes the expulsion of the embryo. It can also cause serious complications for the mother.

NGO Aware Girls counsels those who call its hotline on how such drugs should be used safely and when to seek emergency or professional treatment at a clinic.

“Most of us know women who have died of an abortion,” said Aware Girls co-founder Gulalai Ismail.

Zameena was one of the lucky ones — she knew where to go for help once she decided to terminate her latest pregnancy.

At the other end of the Aware Girls hotline, counsellor Ayeesha reassured and advised her on what medicines to take and in which dosage.

They insist that women must never be alone when they attempt such procedures.

“My work saves women’s lives. When they call, they are willing to do anything to have an abortion,” explained the 26-year-old.

Ayeesha estimated that she fields around 350 calls a month. Most women who contact the NGO know very little about contraception. Access to condoms, the most well known option, is limited and even when they can be bought, it requires the man to agree.

According to official statistics, only around 35 per cent of Pakistani women use any form of non-abortive birth control despite them being inexpensive. Birth control pills cost just Rs20 rupees, for example, while an IUD is available for Rs400 rupees.

But population control is a controversial issue in Pakistan, where large families are prized.

“Authorities have not been able to make this issue an emergency for Pakistan. It is all rhetoric and political gibberish,” says Dr Haroon Ibrahim of the family planning NGO Greenstar,

Zeba Sathar, a demographer in charge of another NGO, the Population Council, branded the nation’s negative attitude to contraception a “systemic failure”.

Prime Minister Imran Khan in December acknowledged the lack of political will on the issue and promised pro-contraception campaigns using the media, cell phones, schools and mosques.

“The mullahs have a key role to play,” he insisted.

But the Council of Pakistani Islamic Ideology, a religious body which advises the government, says otherwise, insisting that family planning is against Islam.

“The birth control campaign at the government level should be immediately stopped and the birth control program should be removed from the economic planning,” the council told AFP.

The charity Marie Stopes, whose clinics provide post-abortion care, has profiled a typical client in Pakistan: aged in her thirties, married at 18, she is poor, uneducated and already has three children.

Such women approach the agency when backstreet abortions go wrong.

“Women are just dying… for the lack of knowledge,” said Xaher Gul, an executive at Marie Stopes.

In 2012, the year of their last study, the Guttmacher Institute estimated there were 2.25 million abortions in Pakistan with 623,000 women treated for post-abortion complications.

“We have failed women in this country,” warned Hassan Mohtashami, former head of the United Nations Development Programme in Pakistan.

He added: “Abortion is not a family planning method.”

The Express Tribune

Related Stories

Dawn: Women seek abortions as birth control

Police releases professor accused of sexual harassment

BHAKKAR: A University of Sarghoda Bhakkar Campus professor was released by authorities after being interrogated over charges of sexually harassing a girl student.

Professor Dr Sajid Iqbal was released on bail after initial investigations. During the interrogation of student S* and Professor Dr Sajid Iqbal, under the supervision of DPO Shaista Nadeem, the former was unable to prove the allegations. Two other students were also included in the investigation. Police stated that S* was also unable to provide any evidence of blackmail or harassment.

DPO Shaista Nadeem said Professor Dr Sajid Iqbal was released on bail, but the investigation is still under way and the professor would be summoned if needed. In a video filmed by the student, which later went viral on social media, she claimed Dr Iqbal sexually harassed her.

On the complaint of the girl’s father, who is a teacher at the Government Model High School in Kilor Kot, Bhakkar, police registered a case against the accused.

On Thursday, local police registered the case against the suspect and arrested him on the premises of the university campus. After Dr Iqbal was taken into custody, professors and lecturers of all the departments boycotted classes and registered their protest in front of the DPO office.

A delegation of professors and lecturers also went to meet DPO Shaista Nadeem. She assured them that the case would be investigated on the basis of merit. After initial investigations, Dr Iqbal was released on bail. Professors, lecturers and other staff of Sargodha University thanked DPO Shaista Nadeem and demanded stern action against ‘blackmailers’.

Dr Iqbal said that the video was edited by someone and posted on social media after adding a sad song to it. He added the person who registered the FIR was different from the one who posted the video on social media.

He claimed this was a pressure tactic to pass the student. The professor said that the accusations had been continuing for the last two years by S* who had been perpetually failing the courses taught by him.  He claimed that the student had also caused a fire in the girls’ hostel and was ejected from the housing facility. She is currently residing in a private hostel.

He continued that S* was also accused of stealing in class and her parents had to issue personal apologies over her behaviour.

The Express Tribune

Related Stories

Dawn: Sexual Harassment

KU hosts Global Women’s Breakfast

KARACHI – Women scholars at all stages of their careers gathered in the Multipurpose Hall of the International Center for Chemical and Biological Sciences (ICCBS), University of Karachi (UoK), to shape, establish collaborations, and talk about women’s progression in chemistry.

The event held as a part of the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry (IUPAC), “Global Women’s Breakfast” which aims to empower women in chemistry. The event was also associated with “the International Day of Women and Girls in Science”, established in 2015 by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) to empower women in science and technology.

Highlighting the importance of the occasion, Prof Dr M Iqbal Choudhary said that at the same time this Global Women’s Breakfast was being held in many countries all over the world. He said that this event was organised to address the challenges women in chemistry faced.

He expressed serious concerns over social compulsions that restricted Pakistani women to work freely for the progression of the country. He regretted that Pakistan was one of a few developing countries where women were deprived to have basic human need of clean toilets in the public places. This deprivation also lock up women at their houses, he pointed out.

We have every reason to celebrate women empowerment, Choudhary said, adding that in previous times, only elite class was sending their women for education, but in recent times the situation is clearly flipped. It is observed that females are in great numbers than males in our higher learning institutions, he said.

As a matter of fact, educating a woman is impacting more important than educating a man, as the female has to take the lead in training the kids of her own, he observed.

Choudhary pointed out that challenge in this situation was higher ratio of females in equation, but they are rarely seen on leading posts in academia and industries. Then there are number of other challenges which both male and female have to find the solution for, he said.

In an open discussion, female members of the ICCBS faculty, including Prof Dr Bina Siddiqui, discussed about the primary causes of why women weren’t more self-confident. The female chemists said that the Global Women’s Breakfast intended to assist women chemists to expand their network of contacts, both locally and internationally.

They pointed out that the common perception of society was that women were delicate and not equal to men as they are not able to carry out hard work like men do. They asserted that as far as inelegance was concerned there is no difference between men and women. Women are equally capable of performing tasks as men do, they said.

In fact, there are few responsibilities which nature gave only to women, like bearing a child, giving birth of a child, nursing and taking care of child and family, the chemistry scholars observed. The nature has made women very strong but what they need is a supportive attitude from family, spouse and society to continue their carrier after completion of education, they said.

The Nation

‘Women to be given opportunities for change in police force’

Police as a first respondent have a pivotal role in combating violence against women and violence can be reduced through effective use of existing support mechanisms, observed police officials, legal experts and other civil society representatives at a consultative gathering here on Wednesday.

The Legal Rights Forum under the umbrella of ‘Pakistan Forum for Democratic Policing’ organised the consultation, titled ‘Role of police in combating violence against women and support mechanisms’, at PMA House Karachi.

Speakers said women and girls had been facing violence and discriminatory behaviours even at their homes, while discrimination at state and society levels had increased their miseries. They said that in every third household women faced various types of violence and less attention was paid to psychological violence, which badly affected the efficiency of women.

Former inspector general of police Niaz Ahmed Siddiqui said structural change in police was crucial and he had been assisting the department through trainings and other interventions so as to create a greater impact.

He said women had great potential and would be given opportunities to bring about a change in the police department. Women police officers should be empowered and given key posts, which would reduce violence against women.

Senior Superintendent of Police East Karachi Captain (retd) Azfar Mahesar said women had been facing discrimination and violence at the hands of close relatives in most of the cases. He emphasised the need to change the mindset and include more human rights-related material in te police training curriculum to sensitise police officers.

Mahesar said the police department had been recruiting directly BPS 16 grade inspectors with law background to resolve legal and other procedural issues to minimise human rights issues. He said over 1,000 inspectors would be hired and they would conduct trainings and sensitise officials on new laws, particularly women-friendly laws.

The SSP said that he had appointed a woman as the first female station house officer in the Khairpur district to challenge the stereotypical mindset. He noted that resistance came but he kept doing the same practice to change the mindset.

He said the police department established a women and children protection cell at regional level and women police officers were dealing with survivors. He called for the need to give privacy with rights to women for empowerment.

Inspector Khurram Awan, focal person for South Zone, said survivor women could easily share their issues with females; therefore, women police officers had been designated to redress their grievances.

He suggested establishing female help desks at each police station to support survivors of gender-based violence. Mahnaz Rehman of Aurat Foundation said everywhere women faced violence and discriminatory behaviours, but due to a continued struggle women had now been challenging the stereotyping and putting up resistance for their rights.

She said that though there were some good laws, women were unable to get benefits from those laws due to lack of awareness and implementation of the laws. LRF executive director Malik Tahir Iqbal, Shariq Ahmed, Manzoor Ahmed, Fouzia Tariq and others said women were resisting discriminatory practices, and this was resulting in a better change, but there was a need to continue advocating for rights at all levels.

They said suggested that violence against women could be controlled through close coordination between police and citizens with mass level behaviour change campaigns through media and other sources.

The News

‘Rising’ encourages women to partake in economic development

KARACHI:Pakistan Society for Training and Development (PSTD) organised a one-day conference, ‘Rising,’ on Wednesday which was attended by a large number of entrepreneurs and women from the corporate sector.

American Consul-General JoAnne Wagner, appreciating the role of women in social and economic development, said that Pakistani women were just as talented as other women in the world and could make their dreams come true.

Highlighting the efforts of the American government to empower women, she said that through US-Pakistan Women Council, that served to facilitate communication between the women of both countries, women were benefitting from the experience of one another.

Similarly, America’s Cultural Exchange Program had also played an important role in strengthening social networks, he added.

PSTD Chief Executive Officer (CEO) Zubina Sadiq said that the purpose of the conference was to strengthen the society by providing training and awareness so that women can also take part in the country’s development.

The conference provided the opportunity to meet successful women and benefit from their experiences.

Habib Bank Limited Retail Products head Danish Hashmi said that only 5% of the women were benefitting from banking facilities. He said that the government and the State Bank of Pakistan had devised a strategy to broaden the circle of banking facilities in the country.

He said that HBL was also bringing forward modern and unique products to make the provision of banking facilities to women easy. Hashmi added that the economic participation of women in modern research was important because women were better at saving. The women also exhibit better abilities in facing risks, he said.

The Express Tribune