MPs boycott sitting over gender ‘discrimination’

By: Azam Khan

ISLAMABAD: Tuesday’s National Assembly session was marred first by thin attendance of lawmakers and then by the opposition parties boycotting the day’s proceedings over the government’s alleged discriminatory policy regarding allocation of development funds, particularly to female legislators.

The conspicuous absence of majority of the members on the treasury benches forced the deputy speaker of the house to suspend the proceedings until Wednesday (tomorrow), which is likely to be the last day of the current session.

Leader of the Opposition Khursheed Shah, who had skipped Monday’ session, said he was unaware of the government’s “discriminatory” policy regarding the opposition and female lawmakers.

However, he questioned the gaping difference in allocation of funds: the ruling Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz’s lawmaker would be allocated Rs50 million and the opposition lawmaker would get only Rs20 million, while there is no allocation for the female legislators.

“How can you ignore the female legislators?” asked Shah as he led the opposition parties’ boycott. Pre-empting the move, Deputy Speaker Murtaza Javed Abbasi adjourned the hearing for the next day.

Unpaid bills

During the proceedings, Water & Power Minister Khawaja Muhammad Asif told the lower house of parliament that the Sindh government needed to pay Rs66 billion in electricity bills.

“The Hyderabad Electric Supply Company and the Hub Power Company are not paying their dues,” he said while responding to a point of order raised by PPP MNA Ayaz Soomro from Sindh. “The federal government had reconciled Rs9 billion with the Sindh government on payable electricity bills, but only Rs600 million have been paid.”

Asif said the federal government had repeatedly asked the Sindh government to identify the amounts payable by its departments and private consumers. “Only Rs9 billion were reconciled. They are not willing to pay a single rupee to the federal government.”

He said the issue of payable electricity bills started during the previous PPP government when the administration had entered an agreement with nine power plants, guaranteeing them payment every month come what may.

The minister said the issue of payments remained unaddressed and now the distribution companies (Discos) in Sindh were on the edge of a disaster because of non-paying customers and uninterrupted payments to nine companies.

The minister said, “I once again request the PPP members and Khursheed Shah to ensure payment for the two Discos.”

As for the Balochistan government, he said the administration needed to pay Rs100 billion. “The amount is fixed for electricity for tube wells in Balochistan, but the owners provide further connections to hotels and residential areas.”

Similarly, he added, police stations and the Water and Sanitation Agency are selling their water and power connections to residents.

Coming back to Sindh, Asif said the K-Electric had asked the Centre for Rs22 billion. “The government is prepared to share the burden of the provincial government, but it should at least pay a sufficient amount from the outstanding Rs66 billion.”

Express Tribune

Broken society

By: HUMA YUSUF

ON Friday evening, I emailed my editor to suggest I write a piece on the growing number of targeted attacks against women in Pakistan. The idea had been brewing for some time, but I was struggling to think what needed to be said beyond the usual tropes about gender and violence. Then came the horrifying news of Sabeen Mahmud’s assassination, and with it the realisation that a society we fool ourselves into thinking is fragile is actually completely broken.

Mahmud is the latest in a line of women who have been targeted, one at a time, for political or symbolic reasons. Her murder comes days after the shooting of Debra Lobo, an assistant professor at a medical college. Before her there was PTI founding member Zahra Shahid Hussain, social activist and urban planner Perween Rahman, and of course, Malala Yousafzai and Benazir Bhutto.

The motives, perpetrators and context for each attack are completely different, offering a macabre laundry list of the types of violence we must contend with in Pakistan, ranging from political and criminal to militant. In many ways, it is simplistic to compare or equate these attacks. But there is something distinctly perverse about a society in which women are targeted in this way.

The reasons for targeting women are obvious: the act is low-cost, high-impact. The targets were in their cars, most of them either unescorted or accompanied by other women — mothers, daughters, school friends — traversing familiar routes, often between their workplace or school and their home. They were vulnerable and exposed, and easy targets for gunmen (it is no coincidence that many of the victims were targeted in Karachi, a city awash with weapons).

The resource outlay to target a woman is minimal, but the terror it produces is pronounced and widespread. With it comes the distinct realisation that the rules of the game have changed — that there may no longer be any rules. There is an audacity to the act that makes it more brutal, that makes the message that is being delivered through the targeting all the stronger. And the impunity that inevitably follows feels just that much more shameful.

Why target women? The act is low-cost, high-impact.

Put simply, the targeting of women exacerbates the fear factor. In a society falling apart, men become accustomed to being scared. But when women are targeted, everyone is scared: women themselves, the children they are meant to nurture, and the men who think it’s their job to protect the women in their lives.

Society is more distraught after such incidents because, despite the many advances of feminism, it is still seen as morally and ethically weaker to target women. Sirajul Haq captured the gist of this kind of thinking in his tweet about Mahmud’s killing, saying only cowards target women. The logic was cruelly distorted earlier this month by the al-Shabab militants who stormed the Garissa University in Kenya: as they went from room to room killing students, they said it was against Islam to hurt women in order to entice female students out of their hiding places. The women who emerged were promptly killed.

Women are of course murdered all the time. They are not immune to terrorist attacks, drone strikes, and criminal violence. But their deaths under these circumstances are the same as those of men or children, stripped of gender, tragic at best, statistical at worst.

Thousands of women also die each year in Pakistan as a result of gender-based violence: so-called honour killings, acid attacks, sexual assaults, kerosene stove blasts. These deaths are no less savage than incidents of politically motivated violence against women, but they are distinct. They are examples of structural violence that ultimately say more about the patriarchal systems in which such violence thrives.

Ironically, the patriarchy that leads to women being killed because of their gender is the same thing that produces extra shock when a woman is gunned down for political reasons. After all, the patriarchy is meant to offer protection to women and bestow a sacred stature upon them. In places like Pakistan where the horrors of patriarchy-driven violence persist alongside the brutality of political assassinations, nothing makes sense any more.

In a homage to Mahmud’s fighting spirit, sense of humour and generosity, I wanted to end this piece on a positive note. Here’s the best I can muster: the silver lining (however tarnished) of these savage incidents is that they demonstrate that we now live in a country where some women feel empowered enough to take a stand and have a voice, and do it effectively enough that someone thinks they’re worth targeting. If these women continue to inspire the rest of us — if even a handful among us can emulate their courage — there may yet be some hope.

Daily Dawn

Head of seminary, 2 others convicted in rape case

By: NISAR AHMAD KHAN

MANSEHRA: The Anti-Terrorism Court, Abbottabad, convicted the head of a seminary and his two accomplices on Thursday for subjecting a First Year girl to rape in a moving car, and sentenced two of them to 14 years’ rigorous imprisonment.

ATC Judge Raja Masood also convicted a co-accused, who was driving the car when his accomplices were committing the crime, to 10 years’ rigorous imprisonment.

The widely reported and condemned rape case took place on May 12 last year when cleric Qari Naseer, who is also the head of a seminary, and his two accomplices, Mohammad Faizan and Hussain Mushtaq, tricked the student into sitting in their car with help of an accomplice, Anam Bibi, a classmate of the victim.

The police arrested Qari Naseer and his two other accomplices and charged them with under the Anti Terrorism Act and different sections of Pakistan Penal Code.

After completion of arguments by the defence and prosecution, the judge pronounced the verdict, observing that the prosecution had proved its case against the three men.

The judge acquitted the female accused in the case.

The judge sentenced Qari Naseer and Mohammad Faizan to undergo14 years’ imprisonment each. The judge also convicted Hussain Mushtaq to undergo 10 years’ rigorous imprisonment for helping the two other convicts by driving the car from Mansehra to Abbottabad when they were committing the crime, though he himself did not take part in the heinous crime.

It was the first case of its nature where convicts raped their victim in a moving car and pushed her out of the vehicle at the Gazikot Township after the incident.

The ATC announced the verdict after hearing the case for about 10 months.

Daily Dawn

National Women’s Day Nation urged to shun gender discrimination

All Pakistanis must set aside gender discrimination and celebrate the National Women’s Day, a milestone achieved after great sacrifices by women activists, if the difference of gender discrimination is over, the country can be put on the path that would lead to development and progress, National Commission on the Status of Women (NCSW) Chairperson, Khawar Mumtaz said on Thursday.

There were many keynote speakers at the seminar that organized by Sindh University Jamshoro to commemorate national women’s day in collaboration with NCSW here at Shaikh Ayaz Auditorium of varsity’s Arts Faculty Building. Dr Misbah Bibi presided over the seminar on behalf of acting Vice-Chancellor Professor Dr Parveen Shah.

The seminar aimed on reflecting the challenges that extremism posed to women in Pakistan & develop a strategy to deal with it and pay tribute to those women who remained on front in movements during one unit and dictatorship of General Zia ul Haq. NCSW Chairperson said the National Women’s Day had been celebrated since 2010.

“The NCSW aims at achieving gender equality in accordance with the Constitution and international commitments,” she said. “We examine policies, programmes and review laws, rules and regulations affecting the status and rights of women.” The NCSW also suggests the repeal, amendment or enactment of new legislation to end discrimination.

She further said even though women had achieved several milestones, “we still have miles to go before we can call it a day”. She deplored the lack of progress on the Domestic Violence Bill. She said not much had been done to stop child marriages either. Ms Mumtaz said the encouraging war-mongering should be checked.

The National Women’s Day should have been celebrated at a national level not by just the University of Sindh, she said. Ajoka Theater Lahore’s Director, Madiha Gohar said, “Extremism is a mindset…it ranges from verbal threats to mental stress and fear.” She said various forms of extremism were on the rise in the KP, the FATA, the Punjab, Sindh & Balochistan provinces.

“Traditions like Swara, child marriages and strict dress codes are on the rise…they have manifested themselves in opposition to education, health and political rights.” Ms Gohar said deprivation of inheritance and adopting a profession of choice were some of the economic problems the women of the country faced.

She also criticised the religious forces and held General Ziaul Haq’s so- called Islamisation policy responsible for the plight of the country’s women. Madiha Gohar further said that she had visited Tando Allahyar and was appalled to see that the flags of the banned organisations were hoisted in every nook and corner of the city.

“Sindh is the soil of Shah Abdul Latif Bhittai, it is land of Sufism so for God’s sake, don’t let the banned religious organisations work here freely”, she said. Tahira Abdullah, a speaker from Karachi, said Balochistan faced three kinds of problems: sectarian violence, Talibanisation and Baloch nationalism. She said extremism must be weeded out.

She said, very little legislation had been done to empower women in the last 10 years other than a toothless honour killings bill and an incomplete set of amendments to the Hudood Ordinance. Uzma Noorani, representing a women’s rights activist Shahnaz Wazir Ali, said that the state had surrendered its writ in every sphere of life. “It is a myth that foreign elements are responsible for the current state of affairs, that people do not vote for religious parties and that poverty is the root cause of extremism,” she said.

“Extremism in the Punjab is most entrenched in the middleclass…that has nothing to do with poverty,” she said. “People do not pay taxes but they generously donate to religious seminaries.” Ms Anis Haroon, an activist for women’s rights said, “You cannot empower a nation without making sure that women are given the right and access to justice. Women are the backbone of a nation…they are the future of a country.”

She said: Some laws and constitutional articles are among the biggest hurdles in providing equal rights to all citizens adding that some sections of the society were promoting extremism and terrorism in the name of religion. “It is too much now, we have to stop such activities, we (women) want freedom and get the right of education, health and other basic facilities,” she said. Attiya Daud, a Sindhi poetess, said the Sindhiyani Tahreek had from its inception adopted a clear stance on the issue of blasphemy laws. She said exploitation of the law for personal interests could not be allowed.

She said discrimination against women frequently started at their homes. Family, she said, was first and foremost responsible for condoning acts of violence against women. She said a real change at the level of the society was possible only if individual families changed their attitude towards women’s rights. Amar Sindh, a well-known writer & activist, said that rights of women, minorities and other marginalized groups could be secured only in a secular and a democratic society.

“A woman in every role, whether it is that of a mother, a wife, a daughter, a sister or a friend, is a lot of love, affection, skill and vigour put together. There is no creature in the world as fragile yet powerful, as sensitive yet tolerable and as gentle yet resolute as a woman.” She said.

Dr Arfana Mallah, a prominent columnist, said that Sindhi women always led the movements whether it was one unit or Zia’s martial law; they continuously remained on front in a bid to bring the dictatorship to an end. NCSW member Kishwer Naheed recited her poem Hum Ghunahgar Aurtain (We sinful women) and received accolades in abundance. She recited some other poems demanding the women’s’ rights, honour and opportunities to move ahead. Malka and Amna sang women’s anthems and received appreciations and admiration from the audience.

Business Recorder

Rape, acid attacks, kidnap: Girls face rising violence in fight for education, says UN

By Reuters

GENEVA: Attacks on schoolgirls and girls’ education are on the rise, according to a new report from the United Nations office of human rights.

The report cited a handful of high-profile attacks in recent years. In Pakistan, in the deadliest attack of this kind in years, the Pakistani Taliban slaughtered over 140 people, including 132 students at Army Public School in December last year. Two years prior, then 15-year-old Malala Yousufzai was shot at close range in the head by a Taliban gunman, making her the face of the struggle to educate girls. She has since completely recovered and was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize at age 17.

Many of the attacks are done in the name of culture or religion, while others are gang-related, notably in El Salvador and other parts of Central America, Veronica Birga, chief of the women’s human rights and gender section at the UN human rights office, said at a presentation to launch the report.

“Attacks against girls accessing education persist and, alarmingly, appear in some countries to be occurring with increasing regularity,” the report said. “In most instances, such attacks form part of broader patterns of violence, inequality and discrimination.” Many of the attacks in at least 70 countries between 2009-2014 involved rape and abduction, the report said.

The Express Tribune