SC constitutes team to arrest culprits involved in Karo-Kari case

Man kills wife

KARACHI: The Supreme Court on Friday directed the Shikarpur police to arrest the culprits involved in the killing of two women by declaring them Kari and holding a Jirga to settle the dispute within a week.

The three member bench headed by Chief Justice Tassaduq Hussain Jillani was hearing the suo moto case on the Jirga in Wazirabad town in Shikarpur to settle tribal dispute in Karo-Kari case.

Two women of the Mahar tribe had allegedly been killed by their parents for having illicit relations with men of the Jagirani tribe. The Jagiranis were fined a total of Rs2.4m for ‘kidnapping’ and ‘having illicit relations’ with the women. The jirga that was presided over by the Pakistan Muslim League-F MNA Ghous Bux Mahar apparently held to settle a tribal dispute and both the parties accepted its decision but no one was penalised for murdering the women.

The court expressed displeasure over the non-arrest of culprits involved in the incident. DIG Larkana Khadim Hussain Rind submitted that raids have been conducted to arrest culprits involved in the killing of women and twelve accused who held the jirga to settle the dispute.

Investigation officer Mohammad Siddique submitted that the case was registered on complaint of Abdullah Mahar about disappearance of his daughters who went to his brother Sanaullah’s house and later it was transpired after the jirga that murders were the result of Karo-Kari. He said that an FIR was registered against the members of the Mahar and Jagirani tribes.

The court directed DIG to constitute investigation team headed by DSP Abdul Qudoos Kalwar who shall conduct investigation into the murder of the women, arrest the culprits involved in both cases and submit the charge sheet before the court.

The News

More jirga ‘justice’

Karo-Kari

BARBARIC customs die hard, and when state representatives are either involved in perpetuating them or look the other way, there are slim chances these practices will be eliminated. Much has been written about the detestable practice of karo-kari, or honour killing, in Sindh; yet despite legal provisions against it little change has been witnessed on the ground. As reported on Tuesday, a jirga held in Wazirabad town of Sindh’s Shikarpur district recently passed a decision in a karo-kari case. Two women of the Mahar tribe had allegedly been killed by their parents for having ‘illicit relations’ with men of the Jagirani tribe. The Jagiranis were fined a total of Rs2.4m for ‘kidnapping’ and ‘having illicit relations’ with the women. The jirga was apparently held to settle a potentially explosive tribal dispute, but while both parties accepted its decision, astonishingly, no one was penalised for murdering the women. Even more shocking, an MNA, the PML-F’s Ghous Baksh Mahar, presided over the jirga.

Why was an MNA, who represents a lawmaking forum, involved in the promotion of jirga ‘justice’, when laws passed by the august house he is a part of have seemingly been violated? Not only has the Supreme Court declared the holding of jirgas unconstitutional, honour killings also contravene the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2004. But how can such a law be enforced when lawmakers themselves are involved in promoting illegal acts? There are also reports that other government officials in upper Sindh quietly support the jirga mechanism to settle disputes. True, such a forum has its utility when it comes to resolving local disputes, especially when the judicial system is notoriously inefficient. But what is totally unacceptable is when these forums condone crimes such as murder and kidnapping. Police authorities have reportedly launched a probe into the Shikarpur incident. For this deplorable practice to be eliminated, the state needs to take action against all those who commit and abet honour killings, despite their connections and clout.

DAWN