LHC suspends sessions court order against Babar Azam

The Lahore High Court (LHC) on Monday suspended the order of a sessions court directing the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) to register a case against Pakistan cricket captain Babar Azam and others in a harassment case.

The court also issued notices to the FIA and Hamiza Mukhtar.

Last week, a sessions court had directed the investigation agency to lodge a case against Azam on Mukhtar’s complaint. She had alleged that she was constantly receiving “threatening messages” from different mobile numbers on WhatsApp. She had said she was continuously blackmailed that the suspects would upload fake pictures of her on social media if she did not accept their demands.

“Since, regular inquiry has been commenced with respect to the complaint of the petitioner. the respondent (FIA) is directed to proceed further with respect to registration of FIR against the culprits within the stipulated time after committing legal formalities,” Additional District and Sessions Judge Hamid Hussain had said in his order.

Justice Asjad Javed Ghural presided over today’s hearing and noted that the cricketer had submitted a new request. “Who conducted the inquiry in this case,” the judge asked, to which Azam’s legal counsel, Barrister Haris Azmat, replied that the FIA had conducted the investigation.

Azmat argued that the sessions court had issued the order in contravention of the law. “The order to register a case was given without hearing the position of Babar Azam,” he said.

In his petition, Azam contended that he was an international cricketer and the captain of the national cricket team in all three formats. It contended that the order passed by the sessions court was an “unreasoned, non-speaking order”.

It further added that the impugned order was in violation of the Prevention of Electronic Crimes and Investigation Rules 2018, while the direction to register an FIR was in violation of rule seven of the same.

The petition urged the LHC to set aside the order issued by the lower court. “It is further prayed that during the pendency of the writ petition, operation of the impugned order may kindly be suspended,” it said.

Earlier this year, the LHC had suspended the operation of an order passed by a sessions court to the Naseerabad police to register a case against Azam on Mukhtar’s complaint.

Mukhtar had previously accused Azam of deceitfully maintaining sexual relations and making false promises of marriage. She had also alleged that she got pregnant in 2015 with his baby but was forced to go through an abortion.

Newspaper: Dawn

LHC takes up Babar Azam’s petition today

LAHORE: The Lahore High Court today (Monday) will take up petition of Pakistan’s cricket captain Babar Azam challenging an order by a sessions’ court directing the FIA to register a case against him under the cybercrime law on a complaint of a woman.

In the petition, the cricketer contended through a counsel that the impugned order passed by an additional district & sessions judge was against the law. He asked the high court to set aside the order.

The lower court had issued the order on a complaint of Hamiza Mukhtar accusing Babar Azam and others of hurling death threats in whatsApp messages through different mobile numbers. The woman said she had been facing continuous blackmailing that the suspects would upload her fake pictures on social media if she did not accept their demands.

The FIA in its report filed with the court said the cricketer did not appear before the investigating officer; however, his elder brother appeared and sought time on behalf of his younger brother for recording of statement.

“Since, regular inquiry has been commenced with respect to the complaint of the petitioner. Thus, respondent (FIA) is directed to proceed further with respect to registration of FIR against the culprits within the stipulated time after committing legal formalities,” said the sessions’ court in the order.

The woman previously levelled allegations of miscarriage/abortion and deceitful intercourse on false assurance of marriage against the cricketer. She accused Azam of maintaining illicit relations and making false promises of marriage. She also alleged that she got pregnant in 2015 with a baby of Babar Azam but on his wish she went for an abortion. Later, they reportedly reached reconciliation.

Newspaper: The News

Lahore court orders registration of FIR against Babar Azam, others in harassment case

A sessions court in Lahore has ordered the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) Cyber Crime Circle to register a first information report (FIR) against Pakistan cricket captain Babar Azam and others in a harassment case, noting that a regular inquiry had already started into the matter.

Judge Hamid Hussain passed the order on the petition of a woman, Hamiza Mukhtar, on Wednesday.

The petitioner alleged that she was constantly receiving “threatening messages” from different mobile numbers on WhatsApp. The unknown persons also used to “threaten and blackmail her that they have her objectionable pictures and videos and will upload [them] on social media in order to harm her repute in society and ruin her life”.

Mukhtar had turned to the FIA to trace the unknown numbers, in the process of which it was found that one of the numbers was registered in the name of one Muhammad Babar Azam, according to a report submitted to the court by the FIA.

The owners of the mobile numbers — Maryam Ahmed, Muhammad Babar and Salme BB — were served notices to join the FIA’s inquiry proceedings to record their version, the report added. Of the three, only Ahmed appeared in front of the agency and denied that she knew the petitioner and had sent her abusive messages.

According to the report, Ahmed had stated that she would provide her mobile phone for technical analysis but she failed to do so.

Babar’s Brother Faisal Azam appeared on behalf of the cricketer and requested the FIA to “wait for some time” to record Babar’s statement. However, Babar has not yet appeared for the inquiry, the report added.

Listing the grounds for the petition, Mukhtar stated that the respondent in the case — SHO Cyber Crime Wing Lahore — had a “duty to register [a] criminal case against accused if from contents of application/complaint or information given to him an offence was made out”.

However, the investigating officer concerned had “not performed his lawful duty […] and had declined to take any legal action due to extraneous reasons”.

In his order, the judge wrote that since a regular inquiry had already commenced on the petitioner’s complaint, the “respondent is ordered to proceed further with respect to registration of FIR against the culprits within the stipulated time after [completion] of legal formalities”. The petition was subsequently disposed of.

Earlier this year, the Lahore High Court (LHC) had suspended the operation of an order passed by a sessions court to the Naseerabad police to register a case against Babar Azam on Mukhtar’s complaint.

Babar’s counsel, Barrister Haris Azmat, told Dawn.com that they would also challenge the latest order in the LHC.

Newspaper: Dawn , The Nation