Four-day workshop on journalists’ safety concludes

Pakistan Press Foundation’s (PPF) Secretary-General Owais Aslam Ali said on Sunday that over 50 journalists had become victim of targeted killings in recent years in Pakistan and there was always lack of proper investigation in our society when it came to investigating murder of a journalist.

“Only two out of 50 murder cases of journalists could be resolved in recent years in the country,” he said while speaking at the concluding session of a four-day workshop titled “Safety and Security Training for Journalists”, organized by PPF in collaboration with Free Press Unlimited at a local hotel.

PPF’s chief consultant Kamila Marvi said: “Women in the field of journalism have more exposure to society, as they have to work in the field where they face more sexual harassments.”

A representative of Hyderabad Press Club, Faheem Siddiqui, suggested that a committee comprising at least two female should be formed in every press club to tackle issues of sexual harassment, where every female journalist should report in case she faced any such problem.

Citizens-Police Liaison Committee’s (CPLC) Assistant Chief Shabbar Malik said: “We should never take a threat as a joke because it could be very dangerous to us. Such a threat should immediately be reported to a nearby police station and you should get information about the criminals who are threatening you by getting help from intelligence agencies or CPLC.”

Clinical psychologist belonging to Karwan-e-Hayat, Muhammed Idrees, said that sparing time from one’s busy and strenuous life to enjoy with family and friends was highly important for the refreshment of mind.

He said life is so busy these days that people usually do not get time to improve their mental health which could result in a mental disorder. “There are many ways to get relief or minimise your mental stress and these include exercise, listing your problems and find their solutions.”

Criticising the media for highlighting severe injuries cases, Idrees said that such exposures could lead to anxiety and depression in the society.

Bytes for All’s Manager (Research), Faheem Zafar, said that leaving digital equipments unsecured, specially mobile phone, was the most vulnerable device as it could be easily traced and through which your complete information could be looked into.

“Journalists are the mirror of society and they have to tell the truth, so there could be many possible enemies who could penetrate their digital accounts to get their personal information and misuse that,” he observed.

Zafar said there are several software and applications which could help encounter cyber threats, such as Spybot. This software could help in leaving no trace to be located by others, while Firewall would tell you what is entering your computer and what is going out of it without getting notice of it,” he added.

He said Chrome and Firefox are reliable browsers, therefore, using Internet Explorer should be avoided, while in e-mail services Hotmail and Yahoo are the most vulnerable services, although Gmail is relevantly better. The manager said opening website with writing https in browser is more secure rather than http which is insecure.

A trainer of Bytes for All, Farhan Hussain, said Facebook privacy settings must be checked from time to time as they very often change it without giving any notification, expose your private things and posts.

“In case there is a threat from cyber crimes to you or somebody is bothering you on mobile, which is usually faced by females, then FIA could be contacted as they have a cyber wing to deal with these kinds of troubles which is very effective and efficient,” he said.

A former master trainer and commandant of Federal Civil Defence Training School (FCDTS), Sarfaraz Ahmed Jafri, said: “Readiness of mind has a key importance for a person at the time of emergency or disaster to apply safety measures and rescue his own life and, if gets chance, others, as well.”

He said there was no alternative for a human life, therefore, it was always necessary to save it first. “Disaster or emergency mostly occur suddenly so, one should always be prepared for that and keep a first aid kit with him at home and while travelling away.”

Jafri said at the time of emergency one is required to check ABC (airway, breathing and circulation) of the victim. “Apply direct pressure to the wound and wash it thoroughly, however if something for example shrapnel or bullet shell penetrates body, it should not be pulled out because bleeding would be uncontrollable if it was pulled out.”

Senior trainer, Sub-Inspector Gul Awan said nobody should come closer to the crime scene or try to touch things around but law-enforcement agencies, because everything, if placed as it was right after the crime, could tell about the criminals through forensic evidences, and the threat of a secondary blast was always looming there. You may cover it closely after the police had completed their investigation.

“Always keep a way out first in your mind before entering any mobbed area. Do not try to run during crossfire but take shelter behind something solid or lay down straight because it is difficult for targeting a person lying down from a distance,” he said.

A DSP, on the occasion, said law-making was direly needed in the society as we were still following slavery-era law (British) in which direct FIR was reported without prior investigation which meant that now the accused could only get bail through court.

Principal of Police Training College, SP Javed, lauded the initiative taken by PPF for educating journalists about crime scene.

FCDTS’s senior trainer Altaf Hussain Dada, PPF’s Sr. Co-ordinator Musawir Shahid, Co-ordinator Naseem Akhter Shaikh, representatives of Hyderabad Press Club, Khuzdar Press Club, Quetta Press Club, Larkana Press Club Mirpurkhas Press Club and Nawabshah Press Club and local media people were also present on the occasion.

Business Recorder

Asma Shirazi Pakistan’s First Female War Correspondent

WASHINGTON: The following release is being issued by the Global Media Forum Training Group:

Pakistan’s Asma Shirazi will receive the 2014 Peter Mackler Award for Courageous and Ethical Journalism on October 23rd, at 6 pm, at the National Press Club in Washington DC.

Asma Shirazi, 38, is Pakistan’s first female war correspondent and has reported on several recent conflicts including the Israel-Lebanon War in 2006, Taliban violence on the Pakistan-Afghanistan border in 2009, and General Pervez Musharraf’s 2007 state of emergency in Pakistan.

Ms. Shirazi hosted two popular television talk shows, including one on Parliamentary affairs entitled “Parliament Cafeteria” which allowed her to become Pakistan’s first female Parliamentary correspondent. The show was banned by General Musharraf.

Undeterred by death threats and personal risk, Ms. Shirazi has demonstrated courage, professionalism and dedication in the search for truth in a country where talk shows are as risky as war reporting.

“We are thrilled to recognize the courage and dedication to journalistic ethics that Ms. Shirazi has displayed every day of her career,” said Camille Mackler, Project Director for the Peter Mackler Award. “At great personal risk, Ms. Shirazi has continued to ensure that unbiased, free information is available throughout Pakistan. She not only epitomizes the values our award seeks to recognize, she continues to be a role model to young women in Pakistan and in all other parts of the world.”

“By awarding Asma Shirazi, we pay tribute to the courage of those who fight for freedom of information in Pakistan. Facing harsh oppression, Shirazi demonstrates every day outstanding journalistic skills,” said Delphine Halgand, US Director, Reporters Without Borders.

“AFP is happy to be associated with this recognition of Asma Shirazi’s great courage and perseverance in reporting on conflict and politics in Pakistan despite the personal dangers she faced,” said David Millikin, AFP’s director for North America.

Pakistan is currently ranked 158th out of 180 countries in the World Press Freedom Index published by Reporters Without Borders. Ms. Shirazi is the second woman to win the Peter Mackler Award.

The Award ceremony will take place on October 23, 2014 at 6PM at the National Press Club in Washington, DC, 529 14th St. N.W, 13th Fl.; Washington, DC 20045. The ceremony will be followed by a networking hour. The ceremony is open to the public. Register now.

SOURCE Global Media Forum Training Group

PR Newswire

Hard work prerequisite for women in media

KARACHI: Participants at a roundtable conference on Wednesday urged better representation of women in Pakistani media, especially in the provinces of Khyber Pakhtunkhua (KP) and Balochistan.

The conference, organised by Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF) at a local hotel to issue ‘women voices in media’, a report about the quantitative analysis of three KP-based newspapers, three Balochistan newspapers and two regional TV stations in both provinces. The report was focused on the content regarding presence of female voices in the news published and broadcast from May 1, 2013 to July 30, 2013.

Sadaf Baig of Centre for International Media Ethics (CIME) told the moot that women constitute almost 50 percent of the Pakistani population but their representation in KP and Balochistan media was alarmingly low.

She said that there was less than one percent representation of women in the stories published in KP-based newspaper while it was one percent in Balochistan-based newspapers. According to the data for primary source of information, out of 14,761 news items, 3,014 were identified as men being the source, with women far behind at only 24 news item regarding them were in KP papers.

In the newspapers of Balochistan, 285 news items were identified as men-sourced and 50 as women-sourced. The media stories with women as sources were unlikely to appear on the front or back pages of the newspapers in both the provinces. Mostly the stories with women as sources published in the middle pages of newspapers papers and generally they were reports about Bollywood female stars.

Coordinator to Chief Minister Sindh on Culture Sharmila Farooqui said that these figures represent a mindset which believed that whenever a woman spoke it was no worth but the same words coming from a man’s mouth increase their credibility. She said that the issue of ratings matters for TV channels, adding showing women as victims increases their ratings. This is why crime shows aired by news channels are a source to increase their rating. She said that women were also responsible for this as they are generally not ready to assert them in social and professional life.

PPF Secretary General Owais Aslam Ali said that women had less representation in media also due to hesitation of female reporters to go outside and cover a story. Generally, the female reporters are assigned only to cover stories related to women issues.
The speakers said with proper education the prevailing trends in Pakistani society could be changed. Pakistani women working in media also have to work hard to attain their due status and the educational institutions should play their role in promoting female literacy in the country, they added.


Daily Times

Women have to fight harder… – An interactive session with a Pakistani journalist in India

Gender discrimination cuts across all political and cultural boundaries around the world, as we have seen and studied extensively in India. Knowing this, it was still tremendously surprising to learn how similar the situation is in Pakistan, as a recent talk in Delhi by Kiran Nazish, an eminent young journalist from Pakistan made clear.

Kiran Nazish shared her firsthand experiences at an interactive session for faculty and students of the O.P. Jindal Global University organised by Dr Keerty Nakray, aiming to promote cross-cultural understanding of Pakistani culture, history and society.

Ms. Nazish is one of the few women journalists in Pakistan who has reported from the frontlines of terror or extreme violence. She has worked in conflict-ridden areas in Baluchistan, FATA and Khyber Pakhtoonkhwa (formerly North West Frontier Province). Sharing her experiences, she brought alive the classroom theory on feminism and marginalisation of women in private and public spaces.

As she narrated experiences of living in a patriarchal and deeply male dominated society that has imposed rigid forms of control on women’s education, occupational pursuits and marriage, it was impossible not to draw comparisons between India and Pakistan. These realities about women’s lives resonate equally on both sides. Those born into privileged families that enjoy political and economic prowess may have different experiences than women from different backgrounds. Yet the face of patriarchy in both countries, otherwise so divided politically, seem to be directed towards taming women who step out of line.

Ms. Nazish’s own experiences highlight the dual difficulties of being a woman and a journalist. Journalists on the frontline regularly face death threats or physical and verbal assaults, although women journalists may be trusted more or seen as less politically threatening.

Asked why she chose fieldwork over the comforts of a newsroom, despite the difficulties, the answer came across clearly: it is passion and commitment to bring the truth in to the spotlight that drives her to work in one of the toughest places in the world for women.

Emotional upheavals are inevitable in a job that can entail witnessing a close friend being killed for speaking the truth, or hear traumatic stories of murder, rape or bombings. This is in addition to a highly competitive work environment wherein women are often denied promotions owing to their limitations regarding field-based assignments or late hours.

The most important point that Kiran Nazish drove home was that women often excel as they have to fight harder to find professional recognition, and therefore often take the job more seriously. She concluded on a poignant note about the hopes and aspirations of the Pakistani youth for a better political leadership to take them to the next generation of development.

My fellow students share these feelings. We believe that it is these hopes and aspirations of the youth that will erase the bitter political and religious hatred that divides us.

Avani is a second year law student, currently pursuing B.A. LL.B at Jindal Global Law School, India

The News

Discourse on women in media: Uks report looks into why female professionals are still sidelined

By: Naveela Khan

KARACHI: The media industry has come a long way from when the only place for women in the work field was at the post of a secretary or as arm candy smiling next to the male talk show host. But while the male journalists in Pakistan may have stopped referring to their female counterparts as ‘lady reporters’, female journalists still feel that professional roles are being defined according to gender.

According to a report by the Uks Research Centre and DANDIA (the Danish international development agency), the growth of women in media is mostly horizontal and not vertical – which means that they are growing in number but not reaching new professional heights. The report, titled ‘Who’s telling our stories? A situational analysis of women in media in Pakistan’, documents a two-year project and was launched on Wednesday.

Media monitoring and content analysis was part of the Uks project, in which qualitative and quantitative analysis of selected print and electronic media were conducted for their gender sensitivity for one week in March 2012 (left). A basic survey was conducted in media houses from across the country to gain an insight into the ratio of male vs female practitioners in the media sector in Islamabad, Lahore, Multan, Quetta, Hyderabad, and Peshawar (right).

The report looks into how the media offices are viewed as an unsafe working environment by parents, also one of the reasons for the low number of women working in the industry as compared to the number of female graduates of media programmes.

Language barriers

According to the report, gender inequality is prevalent more in Urdu print media as compared to the English newspapers. Veteran journalist, Zubeida Mustafa, however, pointed out that it wasn’t only the language but the attitudes that create a working environment. “Language doesn’t make anyone a better journalist,” she said. “The ground reality is that for equality in media, changes in thinking and attitudes at the top level are required.”

Mazhar Abbas, the director current affairs at Express News, was of the view that the newsroom language also created problems in the working space. “The number of women reporters in the print media is not that high also because of the newsroom language. In many channels, female news anchors have separate rooms because of this reason,” said Abbas. Author Bina Shah, however, did not agree and said, “The trend to shelter women in separate room is dangerous – we need to realise that women are strong and a little crassness won’t make them fall apart.”

Changing perceptions

“Compared to earlier years, the number of female workers in the media has increased but at the same time, the dropout rate after graduation has been higher. In our society, people view educational qualifications as a way to get better marriage proposals and that perception has to be changed,” said Prof. Dr Tauseef Ahmed of the Federal Urdu University of Arts, Science and Technology.

“To attract and retain female journalists, we need to provide them with facilities and flexible working hours,” said Bina Shah. “Everyone needs to know that there are no concrete steps to scoring a good husband.”

Sheema Kirmani, renowned classical dancer who was also present at the launch, said, “If women have no place in the society, how are they going to be empowered. The concept of morality is another hindrance as women in the media are often considered of ‘loose character’ in the society.”
In Shah’s opinion, people should not get intimidated by such cultural and moral values. “The women in media play a major role by representing their gender.”

Perception of women by their own gender was brought up by Sadia Mehmood, assistant professor at Karachi University. “Women don’t take themselves seriously so their teachers don’t take them seriously as well. We need to change the whole cultural mindset for real difference.”

Shahida Qazi, a pioneer in journalism proudly said, “I am the first female gold medalist in journalism studies, I joined Dawn as the first female reporter, and later, joined PTV as the first female news editor. There are multiple opportunities for women to work in media – you just have to seize the right one.”

Express Tribune