Educated women in Punjab’s Dhurnal barred from voting by husbands

DHURNAL: Perched on her traditional charpai bed, Naeem Kausir says she would like to vote in Pakistan’s upcoming election — if only the men in her family would let her.

Like all the women in her town, the 60-year-old former headmistress and her seven daughters — six already university-educated — are forbidden from voting by their male elders.

“Whether by her husband, father, son or brother, a woman is forced. She lacks the autonomy to make decisions independently,” said Kausir, covered in a veil in the courtyard of her home.

“These men lack the courage to grant women their rights,” the widow told AFP.

Although voting is a constitutional right for all adults in Pakistan, some rural areas in the socially conservative country are still ruled by a patriarchal system of male village elders who wield significant influence in their communities.

Men claim restrictions meant to ‘protect’ women from political hostilities; ECP can void polls in areas where women are prevented from exercising voting

In the village of Dhurnal in Punjab, spread across crop fields and home to several thousand people, men profess myriad reasons for the ban of more than 50 years.

“Several years ago, during a period of low literacy rates, a council chairman decreed that if men went out to vote, and women followed suit, who would manage the household and childcare responsibilities?” said Malik Muhammad, a member of the village council.

“This disruption, just for one vote, was deemed unnecessary,” he concluded.

Muhammad Aslam, a shopkeeper, claims it is to protect women from “local hostilities” about politics, including a distant occasion that few seem to remember in the village when an argument broke out at a polling station.

Others told AFP it was simply down to “tradition”.

The Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) has stressed that it has the authority to declare the process null and void in any constituency where women are barred from participating.

In reality, progress has been slow outside of cities and in areas that operate under tribal norms, with millions of women still missing from the electoral rolls.

The elders in Dhurnal rely on neighbouring villages to fill a government-imposed quota which maintains that 10 percent of votes cast in every constituency must be by women.

Those who are allowed to vote are often pressured to pick a candidate of a male relative’s choice.

In the mountainous region of Kohistan in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province home to almost 800,000 people, religious clerics last month decreed it un-Islamic for women to take part in electoral campaigns.

Fatima Butt, a legal expert and a women’s rights activist, said women are allowed to vote in Islam, but that religion is often exploited or misunderstood in Pakistan.

“Regardless of their level of education or financial stability, women in Pakistan can only make decisions with the ‘support’ of the men around them,” she said.

Pakistan famously elected the world’s first Muslim woman leader in 1988 — Benazir Bhutto, who introduced policies that boosted education and access to money for women, and fought against religious extremism after military dictator Zia ul-Haq had introduced a new era of Islamisation that rolled back women’s rights.

However, more than 30 years later, only 355 women are competing for national assembly seats in Thursday’s election, compared to 6,094 men, the election commission has said.

Pakistan reserves 60 of the 342 National Assembly seats for women and 10 for religious minorities in the Muslim-majority country, but political parties rarely allow women to contest outside of this quota.

Those who do stand often do so only with the backing of male relatives who are already established in local politics.

“I have never seen any independent candidates contesting elections on their own,” Zara Butt added.

Forty-year-old Robina Kausir, a healthcare worker, said a growing number of women in Dhurnal want to exercise their right to vote but they fear backlash from the community if they do — particularly the looming threat of divorce, a matter of great shame in Pakistani culture.

She credits part of the shift to access to information as a result of the rising use of smartphones and social media.

“These men instil fear in their women — many threaten their wives,” she told AFP.

Robina, backed by her husband, is one of the few prepared to take the risk.

When cricketing legend Imran Khan swept to power in the 2018 election, Robina arranged for a minibus to take women to the local polling station.

Only a handful joined her, but she still marked it as a success and will do the same on Thursday’s election.

“I was abused but I do not care, I will keep fighting for everyone’s right to vote,” Robina said.

Source: Dawn

Old woman dies during police raid on house to ‘recover’ married girl

BAHAWALNAGAR: An elderly woman died allegedly because of police torture during a house raid conducted by a Bakhshan police station team here on Friday night, sans any women personnel, to “recover” a girl who had contracted court marriage without the consent of her family.

The groom’s family, while recording their protest against police, told Dawn that Amir, a resident of Bahawalnagar, who was working in a factory in Sialkot, contracted court marriage with Nighat (also of Sialkot) on Jan 1.

They said that Nighat’s father got registered a kidnap case under section 365 of the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC) with Rangpura police, Sialkot, against Amir and his family members.

However, they said, a court in Sialkot discharged the case after the couple recorded their statements and provided documentary evidence of their marriage.

Police say raid was conducted to comply with court order

Later, after receiving life threats from Nighat’s family, Aamir and his wife left Sialkot, and moved to Bakhshan Khan, where they started living with his (Amir’s) parents.

Meanwhile, on behalf of Nighat’s family, a writ petition was filed against Amir in a court in Chishtian, leveling the same allegations, the court in Sialkot had earlier dismissed as false.

On learning about the fresh writ petition, Amir’s family contacted the Bakhshan Khan police and informed them of the previous court decision. They assured the police that they would appear in the court on the appointed date to present their case.

However, they alleged that on Friday night, a heavy contingent of Bakhshan Khan police forced their entry into Amir’s house without any women personnel, ransacked the place, abused the family members, and tortured his mother, an elderly woman, to death.

The police also took the newlyweds in custody. However, later Amir was released because of his mother’s death.

The family demanded that Punjab chief minister and police inspector general (IG) should take immediate notice of the police highhandedness and strict action be taken against the officals responsible for the incident.

However, district police spokesperson, Zahid Rasool, said the police raided the house to recover a woman, complying with a court order. Terming the death of Amir’s mother natural, he claimed that she was a cancer patient and the police did not torture anyone during the raid.

He said the family’s video statement holding the police responsible for the woman’s death was an “emotional reaction”, claiming that now Amir’s family has recorded another video statement, denying police torture.

Source: Dawn

Woman killed by father-in-law in magistrate’s court

SAHIWAL: A young woman was shot dead on Saturday allegedly by her father-in-law in the courtroom of a judicial magistrate in Pakpattan, where she was to record her statement in a kidnap case.

Police sources say Tehreem (19), a resident of Malka Hans, was married to the son of Shah Nawaz, her maternal uncle, against her will as she wanted to marry her cousin, Zahid Abbas.

Two months back, Tehreem eloped with Zahid, while her father-in-law got registered a kidnap case against him (Zahid).

On Saturday, Tehreem had come to record her statement under section 164 of the PPC in the court of Judicial Magistrate Ijaz Mahmood, where her father-in-law shot her dead, and managed to escape despite police’s presence.

DPO Tariq Walayat, took immediate notice of the incident happening the same day when Punjab Chief Minster Mohsin Naqvi was due in Pakpattan. Later, he stated that the suspect was arrested within two hours of the murder incident.

Farid Nagar police registered a murder case against the suspect.

Sources say the autopsy was conducted at the Pakpattan District Headquarters Hospital.

bail: Additional District and Sessions Judge Rana Tariq Mahmood on Saturday granted bail to Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf-backed candidate Naeem Ibrahim contesting election from PP-196, Arifwala City.

Naeem was required to deposit a Rs100,000 surety bond.

Reports said Naeem Ibrahim’s supporters were gathered outside the Pakpattan district jail, awaiting his release. However, there are concerns among his supporters that he may be arrested by the police or the ACE in connection with another case.

Naeem Ibrahim emerged victorious in the 2018 election from Arifwala on a PTI ticket. He was held by officials of the regional anti-corruption establishment at Multan Airport upon his return from Dubai. Since then, he has been entangled in various corruption cases, undergoing trials in different courts.

Although Naeem obtained bail in one case, he was arrested in another. Despite his inability to actively campaign, PTI workers and supporters are conducting his electoral campaign.

BODY RECOVERED: The body of a missing youth was found one week after his disappearance from a Christian graveyard at village 21 EB, Arifwala tehsil.

Reports said Ahsan Toufeeq (25), a resident of Fazal Colony’s Chowk Kmharain, went missing a week ago. The Arifwala City Police registered a kidnapping case based on a complaint filed by his elder brother, Ihsan Toufeeq. Despite police efforts to locate the missing youth, his body was found in a graveyard on Saturday.

The Saddar police took custody of the body, which was then sent for autopsy, and initiated an investigation into the matter.

Source: Dawn

Kohistani woman determined not to let ‘edict’ foil her election bid

The picturesque beauty of the Kohistan region, which connects Khyber Pakhtunkhwa to Gilgit Baltistan, belies a darker side. The area has made headlines in the past due thanks to religious zealots and violence against women, and has been in the news lately after local clerics issued a purported edict against women’s participation in the electoral process.

But undeterred by these roadblocks and buoyed by the Election Commission’s rejection of the purported fatwa, 34-year-old Sannaya Sabeel aspires to find a place in the provincial legislature.

A Masters in International Relations, Ms Sabeel is the PTI-backed candidate contesting from the PK-33 constituency. She told Dawn she made the decision to enter the political fray after analysing the problems she saw around her. “Given the pervasiveness of poverty-related issues, coupled with the conditions that women are unfortunately subjected to, I was forced to introspect. I decided I would need a better platform to tackle and solve my people’s problems.”

Previously, Ms Sabeel has been involved in welfare initiatives. She assisted individuals in receiving grants under the Benazir Income Support Programme(BISP). She has also spent time working on projects relating to access to education and infrastructure development to boost the region’s trade linkages.

The purported edict by a group of Kohistan clerics, which threatened to throw a spanner in the works of her campaign, had declared that both women canvassing for elections and individuals voting for a candidate with views that ‘contradict the Islamic system’, were ‘great sins’.

But Ms Sabeel questions the rationale behind the declaration, drawing parallels with the wider Islamic world, where women do play an active role in public life, such as Saudi Arabia.

“They (the clerics) believe women cannot contest and/or cast votes. They are adamant on maintaining prevailing socio-political structures. Some of the scholars are associated with the JUI-F and even they have candidates who are contesting. They should have highlighted the importance of the pardah (veil), or certain details about the way women should campaign,” she says.

Apart from the cultural and religious hurdles in her path, Ms Sabeel will also encounter political hurdles in her path to the provincial legislature.

In PK-33, she is up against Junaidur Rehman Qureshi of the PPP and Ismat Ullah, who is contesting under the banner of the JUI-F.

If she succeeds, she plans to contribute to reforms in the education sector. The region of Kohistan has a literacy rate of around 20 per cent, which she says is dreadfully low. “I will increase the quality [of instruction] and the number of students that are enrolled. If we educate both boys and girls on Islamic teachings and cultural mores, we will be able to make inroads,” she says.

Source: Dawn

‘Mainstream parties have failed to award 5pc tickets to women

The Aurat Foundation, a civil society organisation striving to secure women’s rights in the country, has expressed serious concerns that some of the mainstream political parties have failed to award a minimum of five per cent of tickets to female candidates to contest the upcoming general elections on the general seats of the national and provincial assemblies as per the requirement of the Elections Act, 2017.

to this effect was conveyed by the Aurat Foundation in a letter sent on Saturday by its Executive Director Naeem Ahmed Mirza to the chief election commissioner (CEC) in Islamabad.

The Aurat Foundation said in the letter that it had undertaken an analysis of eight political parties contesting elections for the National Assembly and the four provincial assemblies to see if the political parties had complied with the provisions of the Elections Act, 2017, safeguarding women’s rights.

“We are dismayed to find that some political parties have not observed the legal requirement under Section 206 of the said act and Section 6 of the code of conduct for political parties to award a minimum of five per cent tickets to women candidates on general seats,” writes Mirza.

On the other hand, some political parties complied with the said sections, which is a commendable gesture towards women’s political participation, he adds in the letter.

“We would like to bring the following facts to the knowledge, attention and immediate action of the ECP [Election Commission of Pakistan]: 1. Certain political parties have complied with Section 206 of the Elections Act, 2017, and have awarded the minimum required five per cent party tickets to women on general seats.

“2. Certain political parties have violated Section 206 of the Elections Act, 2017, and have awarded less than the minimum required five per cent party tickets to women on general seats, which requires strict legal action against these political parties as per Section 217(1) of the said act.”

The letter stated that political parties submit an affidavit during the process of election schedule that they had complied with the provisions of the Elections Act, including Section 206.

If they have not met the minimum requirement of awarding five per cent tickets to women on general seats, this should be considered a case of “false declaration of information”, Mirza pointed out.

The Aurat Foundation had written to the CEC on January 31 on this issue, requesting for an appropriate legal action, then an official of the ECP spoke to a foundation official and briefly discussed the issue the next day, reads the letter.

As regards the NA, the analysis shows that the Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians (PPPP), the Jamaat-e-Islami, the Awami National Party (ANP), the Tehreek Labbaik Pakistan (TLP), the Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam-Fazl (JUI-F) and the Balochistan National Party have not met the requirement of awarding at least five per cent of their party tickets to women on general seats.

For the Punjab Assembly, the findings are that the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N), the PPPP, the JI, the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM) and the TLP have not met the requirement of awarding at least five per cent of their party tickets to women on general seats.

For the Sindh Assembly, the findings are that the MQM, the ANP and the TLP have not met the requirement of awarding at least five per cent of their party tickets to women on general seats

For the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Assembly, the findings are that the PML-N, the MQM, the JI and the JUI-F have not met the requirement of awarding at least five per cent of their party tickets to women on general seats.

For the Balochistan Assembly, the findings are that the PML-N, the MQM, the PPP, the ANP, the TLP and the JUI-F have not met the requirement of awarding at least five per cent of their party tickets to women on general seats.

This is to be noted that Section 206 of the Elections Act, 2017, needs to be read with Section 6 of the Code of Conduct for Political Parties, which clearly states that political parties would award a minimum of five per cent general seat tickets to women in each assembly: the NA and the four PAs of Pakistan.

The punishment for the violation of any provision of the Elections Act, 2017, by the political parties is provided in Section 217 of the said act.

Unfortunately, the letter points out, political parties have shown apathy towards female politicians/candidates, and are not ready to mainstream their participation in the electoral process.

“This is to be noted that allotting five per cent general seat tickets to women is a legal requirement, and if not complied with by political parties, they cannot be given election symbols, and cannot contest elections as a political party,” reads the letter.

“It cannot be presumed that political parties are not aware of this obligation for two reasons: firstly, all parties submit an affidavit to the ECP that they have allotted five per cent tickets to women, and, secondly, because most of the mainstream parties, including the PPPP, the PML-N, the PTI [Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf], the ANP and even the TLP, fulfilled this requirement in the general elections 2018.” The Aurat Foundation urged the ECP to take notice of this violation of the Elections Act, 2017, and the code of conduct because the five per cent restriction is already a low ceiling, and if parties continue to show disregard for women in providing them opportunities to mainstream them into electoral processes, it would mean denying half the population of their due fundamental rights under the constitution.

The Aurat Foundation, through this complaint, requested the ECP to take cognisance of the matter with immediate effect, and take strict action under Section 217 and other provisions of laws against the political parties who have defied the provision of the Elections Act, 2017, and the code of conduct.

The letter stressed that it is high time that the ECP accords importance to women that they deserve, and enforces its laws on all political parties without any discrimination.

Source: The News