Two women murdered by their husbands

LAHORE: Two women were subjected to domestic violence and murdered by their husbands in different parts of the City on Monday. In another incident, a man shaved the head of his wife after a dispute.

The first case was reported in Iqbal Town where the suspect Tahir Munir had a dispute with his wife Naheed Tahir. According to Usman, victim’s son, his father turned violent after exchange of harsh words and attacked his mother with a knife. His sister and cousin tried to save her. However, she received fatal injuries and was shifted to Sheikh Zayed Hospital where she could not survive and died during the treatment. A murder case was registered against the suspect and the Police said that he has been arrested.

The other incident was reported in Bhogiwal, Shalimar. On the day of the incident, the husband strangled the victim with a scarf after a brief exchange of words. The victim Hina 22 died on the spot and her body was moved for autopsy. The suspect had fled from the scene. Police said that they were investigating the matter and searching for the suspect. In another incident reported in Sattokatla, a drunk man tortured his wife and shaved her head. The victim Humera Bibi had made a call at 15 that her husband tortured her and shaved her hair with a scissor. Police have arrested the suspect Kashif.

Source: The News

Can Karachi’s women-only pink buses drive change in Pakistan?

At precisely 1.40pm, the bright pink bus packed with women leaves the depot and snakes its way through Karachi’s traffic. Two female conductors walk the aisle collecting the 50-rupee fare. This is the first women-only bus service in Pakistan’s Sindh province.

Every 20 minutes during rush hour and every hour at quieter times, six pink air-conditioned buses run along one of the city’s busiest routes from Frere Hall to Clifton Bridge. “If this is successful, we can bring in more buses throughout the city, and eventually all of Sindh,” says Sharjeel Memon, the province’s transport minister.

Memon wants to make public transport safer and easier for women to use. “We have assessed that 50 per cent of the commuters during rush hour are women and there is not enough space in the bus for them to ride in a dignified manner.”

Launched on 1 February, the new service is Pakistan’s second attempt to introduce public transport that protects women from harassment. The first, run as a public-private partnership in Lahore in 2012, ended after two years when the government pulled funding.

For decades, buses in Pakistan have had women-only sections. But, says Arshia Malik, 32, who takes the bus to work as a nanny in the upmarket area of Clifton, the segregation didn’t stop men “touching your behind or rubbing your shoulder” while getting off the bus. “I would love to ride on the pink buses and ride without bracing myself for an untoward experience.”

Raakhi Matan, 35, a domestic worker, says woman have to be alert on public transport at all times. Touching and lewd remarks from men are common. On one occasion, Matan says she took off her slipper to hit a perpetrator, while everyone looked at her horrified. “I’ve stopped caring [what people think] and do not feel mortified anymore.”

Matan, who has a 15-minute commute, welcomes the new service. “I will feel much safer on an all-women bus.” Dr Hadia Majid, an associate professor at Lahore University, has been researching transportation and its links to women’s participation in the labour market. She sees the pink buses as a positive step in encouraging more women into the workplace.

Poor public transport, she says, has been a contributing factor in Pakistan’s dismally low proportion of women in the labour force. In 2021, women made up 20.6 per cent of the country’s workforce. Harassment was not the only obstacle.

Inadequate transport meant women often had to take more expensive taxis or rely on lifts from relatives. “This limits the times and the places that they can work because it ties them to male kin’s timings and place of work.”

It also makes it harder for women to look further afield to find work. “So, unless there is dire need, it’s easier and preferable for women to just sit at home,” Majid says. The pink buses are part of the city administration’s wider public transport improvement plans.

The Green Line bus rapid transit (BRT), connecting Karachi’s northern suburbs with the city centre, was launched in January last year, six years after construction began. More than 12 million people have so far used the BRT, and other routes are planned.

Arooj Abbasi, who works in hospitality, is excited at the prospect of women-only buses. “Our working hours start later in the day, from 3pm and up to midnight. Many young women who want to join this line of work are deterred by the timing as they know they will not get reliable transport home at night. But if these pink buses can provide that safety, many women will come out of their homes and work.”

Others point to the wider problems. University student Hiba Hasan Fasihi, 19, is sceptical about whether a pink bus can “resolve the way men look at women” but says she will use the service. “The pink buses can be used during rush hour when there can be a lot of pushing and shoving.”

Source: The News

Women winter sports festival begins in AJK today

MUZAFFARABAD: The Azad Jammu and Kashmir Winter Sports Association (AJKWSA) and the AJK Sports Department are hosting the 2023 National Women Winter Sports Championship (Saadia Khan Cup) and 3rd Ganga Choti Winter Sports Festival from Feb 7 (today), an organiser said on Monday.

“This is the first time Azad Kashmir is holding a women’s winter sports national championship wherein more than 80 female athletes will contest for the Saadia Khan Cup,” Raja Aqeel Khurshid, secretary general of the AJKWSA, told Dawn

The female athletes will represent eight teams from AJK, Punjab, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Islamabad Capital Territory (ICT), Gilgit-Baltistan (GB), Pakistan Air Force and Adventure Foundation Pakistan, he said.

Mr Khurshid said that more than 40 male athletes from different regional clubs of AJK, Punjab, KP, GB, and ICT would separately compete in the 3rd Ganga Choti Winter Sports event, he said.

Ganga Choti lies at an altitude of 9,990 feet in AJK’s Bagh district, 7 kilometres ahead of the 7,000 feet high tourist resort of Sudhan Gali.

The athletes, Mr Khurshid said, would contest for medals in Slalom and Giant Slalom categories in Alpine Skiing and Giant Slalom and Parallel Giant Slalom in Snowboarding.

He said AJK Prime Minister Sardar Tanveer Ilays was most likely to be the chief guest at the closing ceremony of the event on Feb 12.

Athletes would demonstrate their skiing and snowboarding skills before the distribution of medals and other awards to the winners at the closing ceremony, where local artists would also perform at a Kashmiri cultural show, he added.

The sporting event, Mr Khurshid said, was part of the AJK winter sports calendar, whereby Alpine Skiing training camps for the local youth were held between Jan 28 and Feb 6 at the 9,500 feet high Pir Chinasi, 9,000 feet high Toli Pir and 7,000 feet high Sudhan Gali, on the outskirts of Muzaffarabad, Rawalakot and Bagh, respectively.

He said the 5th Arang Kel Championship had been scheduled for mid-March this year.

He maintained that the winter and ice sports activities and competitions had become a regular activity in AJK since 2019 after the AJKWSA had held the first-ever winter sports event in the territory at 8,379 feet high Arang Kel in Neelum valley.

According to him, AJK had been naturally blessed with the best slopes and spots -technically suitable for Alpine Skiing and Ice Sports – which were hardly three to four-hour drive from Islamabad, thus making the territory an attractive destination for snow and ice sport lovers and sightseers.

However, he said, development of a reasonable infrastructure and facilities as well as a comprehensive and realistic policy with clear and rational short-term and long-term goals was a must on the part of the AJK government to achieve this goal.

He said he had recently called on the AJK premier who had assured him of his support in installing chairlifts and construction of ice rinks at four locations to promote winter sports.

Source: Dawn

No pardon for rape

AN important aspect of procedural law pertaining to the crime of rape, and one that most certainly serves the cause of justice, was recently reiterated in a sessions court in Karachi.

In a case where a school teacher was sexually assaulted in Karachi in March 2017, the court found the accused guilty and rejected a compromise between him and the victim’s father as a basis of acquittal.

Holding that an out-of-court settlement has no legal value in rape cases, the judge sentenced the defendant to 10 years behind bars. Her approach adhered to the law: the crime of rape is not included among the compoundable offences listed under Section 345 of the Criminal Procedure Code, which expressly says “No offence shall be compounded except as provided by this section”.

Nevertheless, courts still make appalling errors of judgement. In 2012, a trial court acquitted men accused of gang rape after they came to an out-of-court settlement with the father of the victim.

Fortunately, the Supreme Court struck down the lower court’s ruling. But similar travesties of justice continue to take place. For example, in December 2022, the Peshawar High Court set aside the sentence of life imprisonment awarded to a man for sexual assault because he married the victim as a result of a compromise.

Cultural filters and biases can often lead to faulty applications of the law. In a deeply inequitable society, the compounding of offences can lead to outcomes completely at odds with the principles of justice.

This is perhaps most starkly seen in cases of ‘honour killing’ where, unlike other types of murder, the families of the victims and the perpetrators are the same. This has allowed murderers to go free when the victims’ next of kin have ‘pardoned’ them — a grotesque iteration of ‘keeping it in the family’.

After the public outrage at the murder of social media celebrity Qandeel Baloch at the hands of her brother, legislators brought an amendment to the relevant law. Fundamentally, this amendment changed nothing. Honour killing remains compoundable; the court continues, as before, to have discretionary power to award punishment to perpetrators even if they are pardoned by the family of the victim.

Only the minimum punishment that may be awarded has been enhanced — from 10 years’ imprisonment to imprisonment for life.

The acquittal of Qandeel’s brother on appeal by the Lahore High Court is further evidence that the law needs revision, but it also offers an insight into society’s misogynistic bent.

However, in most cases of murder, even willful murder, the deciding factor in whether justice is done is the social standing of the victim’s family. If they can be browbeaten into a ‘compromise’, then killers walk free. Surely those who commit this most terrible of crimes should not get away with it.

Source: Dawn (Editorial)

Islamabad police chief given 24 hours to submit report in National Assembly (NA) over F-9 rape

ISLAMABAD: Days after a woman was raped by two armed men in F-9 Park, National Assembly Deputy Speaker Zahid Akram Durrani on Monday directed the police chief to take action against the culprits and submit a report in the house within 24 hours.

The deputy speaker gave the ruling when a number of lawmakers drew the attention of the house to the rape incident and called for action against police officials responsible for the security of the park.

Speaking on a point of order, Maulana Abdul Akbar Chitrali alluded to the incident and said there was no writ of the state. Mohsin Dawar termed the incident highly disgraceful for the state and said nothing could be more humiliating than such incidents.

The MNA demanded the presence of the interior minister in parliament to give lawmakers a briefing regarding the incident. He also sought regular updates from police regarding the investigation into the crime.

Protesters gather outside park’s Bolan Gate to express pain,anger over incident

“Who was responsible for the negligence,” MNA Dawar questioned. What would be the situation in other parts of the country if such an incident could take place inside a central park of the federal capital, the North Waziristan MNA wondered.

MNA Shahida Rehmani said that she wrote a letter to the Islamabad IG and asked for a report on the incident. She said this incident was a result of a mindset that perpetuated victim-blaming. It is the responsibility of the state to protect the women even if they go outside at 2am, MNA Rehmani added.

MNA Rohail Asghar asked who was responsible for the safety of public places and sought an update on similar incidents being probed by police.

Meanwhile, police said the investigators have shared a sketch of one of the culprits and circulated it to get help in the identification of the culprits. Police added that they were also working on geo-fencing to trace the culprits. A forensic team also visited the crime scene four days after the incident to collect evidence, they added.

Other police officers said that such incidents take place when police officials forget their prime duty of protecting the lives and property of the people and engage in other unconcerned businesses that are not mentioned in the Police Rules.

Protest outside F-9 Park

More than a hundred protesters, mostly young women, gathered outside the Bolan Gate to express solidarity with the survivor and demand accountability over an unabated rise in violence against women.

The demonstration organised by the Women Democratic Forum lasted for more than an hour and ended at dusk after the participants marched to the park and hung their dupattas (scarves) on its gate as a token of solidarity.

In her address to the protesters, rights activist Ismat Shahjahan said a peaceful future for “our children” can only be achieved through seismic social change, since a system that does not protect “women and children” should be abolished.

As she called out the apathy of the political elite, Ms Shahjahan said they wanted to ask the state who was responsible for the prevalent state of affairs, particularly the spike in violence against women and other minorities.

Demanding accountability, Ms Shahjahan questioned how come police officials and the CDA staffers failed to stop the rape on the park’s premises.

Activist Farzana Bari said the turnout at the protest was “disappointing” since this gruesome act should have shaken the nation. She added that the government needed to take measures to make public spaces safe for women and other vulnerable groups.

Ariba, one of the organisers, told Dawn that she hoped that more people would have come out to the protest, but the turnout was disappointing. “As a nation, we are dead inside,” she added.— Additional reporting by Zaki Abbas

Source: Dawn